Robert Hooke: Enemy of the Isaac Newton

Date:

Robert Hooke Empirical Law

I would like to pay homage to an unsung hero of Science Robert Hooke (1635-1703) who had the misfortune of making an enemy of Isaac Newton (1642-1726) which to say the least was not best thing to do. Posterity will recollect that Hooke is credited with the law that bears his name (Hooke’s law) that one learns as a young Physics student but quite frankly, this is not the most flattering law.

Hooke’s Law
Hooke’s Law explains the relationship between force, distance, and deformation of objects (i.e., compression or extension). The law notes that the required force to compress or extend an object is linearly proportional to the distance. Therefore, to move an object in an direction, by force x, then as the distance doubles, force may also be estimated as 2X. Therefore, we can use the distance as contact (k) We can state the law as Fs = kx.

Contribution to Math and Science

Hooke is also credited for observing microorganisms, creating his famed micrographia (small drawings) in which he coined the term ”cell” for biological cells as what he observed, as he put it, reminded him of prison cells.

Hooke was educated at Oxford, and there is today the Robert Hooke Building (Cambridge having the Isaac Newton Institute); Hooke was a polymath and the 9th Gresham Professor. I have been fortunate to meet and work with many such professors, including Raymond Flood (Oxford line manager) and Robin Wilson (son of the late PM, Harold), who delivered talks at an LSE Summer school in Mathematics that I used to direct. I have also been fortunate to discuss Mathematics with another Gresham Professor, namely Christopher Zeeman(1925-2016), again at Oxford after he gave an impromptu talk on Euclid during a History of Mathematics symposium.

Returning to Hooke, he postulated the inverse square law of gravity, but alas he was not as Mathematically competent as Newton, who used the three laws of planetary motion of Kepler (1571-1830) and was able to Mathematically verify that only with an inverse square law could one arrive at elliptical planetary orbits. Hooke also helped Boyle (1627-1691) with his gas experiments, arriving at the so-called Boyle’s law of ideal gases. Hooke also worked with Wren (1632-1723) after the great fire of London.

Robert Hooke Confronts Newton

Hooke and Newton did temporarily reconcile their differences but remained mortal enemies during the later parts of their lives so much so that Newton had every portrait of Hooke at the Royal Society burnt. Newton was quite a would-be arsonist, and it is perhaps well known as a teen, he made a list of his past sins such as: “Threatening my father and mother Smith to burn them and the house over them.”

The legendary quote often attributed to Newton, which many authors believe demonstrates Newton’s magnanimity, is:

“If I have seen further [than others], it is by standing on the shoulders of giants – I. Newton.”

However, this quote is nothing of the kind, it was a direct attack on Hooke as he was short and a hunchback, so Newton was being cruel on two counts. In 1686, when the first book of Newton’s Principia was presented to the Royal Society, Hooke claimed that he had prompted Newton with the idea of Gravity, advising him that:

”The rule of the decrease of Gravity, being reciprocally as the squares of the distances from the Center”.

Isn’t it just beautiful how these giants enunciated their laws in this case the inverse square law?

Alas, once again, I have run out of space and must end here.

Disclaimer

The content presented in this article is the result of the author's original research. The author is solely responsible for ensuring the accuracy, authenticity, and originality of the work, including conducting plagiarism checks. No liability or responsibility is assumed by any third party for the content, findings, or opinions expressed in this article. The views and conclusions drawn herein are those of the author alone.

Author

  • Dr Vasos Pavlika has a BSc in Physics and Mathematics, a MSc in Applied Mathematics, and a two-volume PhD thesis in Mathematical Physics (Magnetostatics and Fluid Dynamics).
    Vasos has 30+ years of experience in lecturing, he has been a Field Chair, Senior lecturer and is currently Associate Professor (Teaching) at University College London. Vasos has been involved with many HE institutions including: the University of East London, the University of Gloucestershire, the University of Westminster, SOAS University of London (both on-campus and online), Into City University, St George’s University of London, Goldsmiths College University of London (online and on-campus), the London School of Economics and Political Science, the Department for Continuing Education University of Cambridge and the Open University.

    View all posts

Share post:

Subscribe

Masketer

spot_imgspot_img

Popular

More like this
Related

Leonhard Euler: The Mathematician Who Revolutionized the Field

Where does one start regarding Leonhard Euler (1707-1783).? We...

Tracing the Evolution of Newton’s Revolutionary Ideas

In 1726, writer  William Stukeley had a conversation with...

Albert Einstein: A Revolutionary Journey Through Physics

Albert Einstein claims that one of his most profound...

Wolfgang Pauli: Insights of the Quantum Principles and Scientific Vigor

I recall learning about Wolfgang Pauli theorem as an...